Hubs for circularity for industrialised urban peripheral areas (Processes4Planet partnership) (IA)

Call updates

May 24, 2024 11:16:07 PM

CALL UPDATE: FLASH EVALUATION RESULTS
HORIZON-CL4-2024-TWIN-TRANSITION-01

EVALUATION results

Published: 07.12.2022

Deadline: 07.02.2024

Available budget: EUR 251,000,000

The results of the evaluation for each topic are as follows:

* Proposals with the same score were ranked according to the priority order procedure set out in the call conditions (for HE, in the General Annexes to the Work Programme or specific arrangements in the specific call/topic conditions).

Summary of observer report:

The evaluation for the HORIZON-CL4-2024-TWIN-TRANSITION-01 call was done completely remote. The evaluation process was clearly visible and transparent to the Observer at all times. The Independent Observer had at all times complete freedom to perform her work and was served promptly with information when asked for. The Call Coordination team of the HaDEA Unit provided the Observer with all the briefing materials and presentations issued to the experts in the remote phase including a SEP account for monitoring.

Throughout the process, complete fairness and transparency were evident and each proposal was evaluated according to defined procedures against the defined award criteria. No case of non-impartial behaviour of experts could be observed. Evaluation criteria were handled in a transparent and fair manner regarding all proposals and in all call topics. 

The entire evaluation process with its applied procedures was assessed by the Independent Observer. The overall quality of the complete remote evaluation process can be stated as excellent in the European context, impartial, and highly efficient. It was very professionally managed by the HaDEA Unit.

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

We recently informed the applicants about the evaluation results for their proposals.

For questions, please contact the Research Enquiry Service.

Feb 7, 2024 8:55:13 PM

PROPOSAL SUBMISSION 

Call HORIZON-CL4-2024-TWIN-TRANSITION-01 was closed on 07/02/2024. 

270 proposals have been submitted. 

The breakdown per topic: 

HORIZON-CL4-2024-TWIN-TRANSITION-01-38: 6 proposals 

Evaluation results are expected to be communicated in the 2nd half of June 2024.

Sep 19, 2023 12:00:04 AM

The submission session is now available for: HORIZON-CL4-2024-TWIN-TRANSITION-01-38(HORIZON-IA)

Hubs for circularity for industrialised urban peripheral areas (Processes4Planet partnership) (IA)

TOPIC ID: HORIZON-CL4-2024-TWIN-TRANSITION-01-38

Programme: Horizon Europe Framework Programme (HORIZON)
Call: TWIN GREEN AND DIGITAL TRANSITION 2024 (HORIZON-CL4-2024-TWIN-TRANSITION-01)
Type of action: HORIZON-IA HORIZON Innovation Actions
Type of MGA: HORIZON Action Grant Budget-Based [HORIZON-AG]
Deadline model: single-stage
Planned opening date: 19 September 2023
Deadline date: 07 February 2024 17:00:00 Brussels time

ExpectedOutcome:
Projects outcomes will enable achievement of the objectives of Processes4Planet partnership by demonstrating hubs for circularity (H4Cs) concepts, fostering circularity within and beyond process industries and driving the partnership’s innovation portfolio towards “First of a kind” demonstrators to de-risk investment for subsequent roll-out. (P4Planet operational objectives 8 and 9).

Projects are expected to contribute to the following outcomes:

Demonstrate zero urban waste in a near commercial scale environment through systemic resource recovery as alternative material feedstock; a decrease of GHG emissions is also expected by explicitly addressing the reduced flow of goods (due to geographical proximity);
Reduce the freshwater consumption of the urban area by 50%, and re-use 90% of the solid waste generated by the water treatment;
Citizens living in cities will benefit from a healthier environment through industrial/urban symbiosis by lowering emissions through circular and renewable energy sources and waste reduction;
Use urban/industrial symbiosis and cross-sectorial cooperation to pave the way for achieving the EU Green Deal and “Fit for 55” package objectives: providing recommendations for optimized regional framework conditions by highlighting barriers and suitable innovation-oriented policies and looking for possible synergies with the cities selected by the Cities Mission[1] .
Scope:
Urban areas with high volumes of waste (household and end of life consumer waste) should closely interact with adjacent industries to jointly minimize their CO2 footprint and improve their waste management, thus contributing together to the valorisation of secondary materials and overall circularity. The hubs for circularity (H4C) concept is a pathway to exploit local synergies for the deployment of innovative solutions engaging regional resource management actors in strategic nodes where novel value chains valorising a significant part of end-of-life wastes could connect within and across regions.

The concept of Industrial-Urban Symbiosis (I-US) should be demonstrated at semi-industrial scale[2], by systemically re-integrating the flow of urban wastes in process industries and, where applicable downstream in manufacturing, construction, and other industries. Full attention should be paid on upcycling of secondary materials or products instead of downcycling.

Proposals are expected to address:

A systemic solution for a H4C including technological and non-technological as well as regional and interregional aspects: closing circularity loops for mixed/combined materials streams based on upcycling and process-based approach to a range of recycling solutions including conversion and downstream, complex multi-material streams, valorisation of waste streams (urban mining);
Proposals can address either materials, water or energy, or a combination of those. Management and processing of secondary resource streams through e.g., collection, disassembly, sorting, purification, concentration, recycling (including but not limited to chemical, metallurgical, or bio-based resources), logistics and trading for their valorisation for the use as feedstock for other plants and companies across sectors and/or across value chains. Connections with manufacturing industries are expected. The remaining non-recyclable fractions will be used to optimal energy recovery;
Digital tool, recycling and sensor-based waste sorting, modelling tools, including material passport and information on material streams, as basis for resource management towards fully integrated LCA and Material Flow Analysis MFA (on diverse levels) and for creating transparency and matchmaking opportunities across hubs. Prepare for tagging/matrix for complex consumer products and innovative approach to end-of life materials;
Establish IT infrastructures and tools that provide a secure basis for the integrated management and the preservation of confidentiality of sensitive data, it might not be in the same location as the demonstrator and serve the needs of multiple hubs;
Consider when applicable the co-development of industrial decarbonization strategies with urban district heating networks, i.e., based on a socio-economic optimum in the cascading re-use of waste heat and using the district heating network to supply low temperature process heat[3];
Use established reporting methodologies for the assessment of industrial symbiosis activities and exchanges, including Symbiosis Readiness Levels (SRLs) and best practices established by the European H4C Community of Practice (ECoP). In addition, interact with the ECoP for support, best practice and knowledge exchange on technological and non-technological issues;
Plan in detail the replication and adaption of the concept, including the simulation and the business case and exploitation strategy of the First of a Kind hubs, in two to three alternative locations in close cooperation with the relevant local actors. The replication cases should be part of the proposal. Include local and regional authorities in an active collaboration to create favourable and coherent place-based framework conditions;
Favour participative management with the local community and study the evolution of the social impact of the hub, whilst also considering gender perspective and inclusiveness;
Implement a social innovation action involving at least one of the local community actors and, additional actions to facilitate relations and to involve the local community actors e.g., exchanging knowledge with the educational establishments and developing flexible learning resources;
Include a plan to extend the hub to additional players parties (especially waste management and associations, new market entries and other relevant stakeholders) who also should benefit and multiply the local/regional synergies in the co-implementation of the identified innovations and solutions within the next five years.
Proposals submitted under this topic should include a business case and exploitation strategy, as outlined in the introduction to this Destination As a project output a more elaborated exploitation plan should be developed including preliminary plans for scalability, commercialisation, and deployment (feasibility study, business plan and financial model) indicating the possible funding sources to be potentially used (e.g., Innovation Fund, LIFE, InvestEU, ESIF).

Relevant indicators and metrics, with baseline values, should be stated clearly in the proposal. Research must build on existing standards or contribute to standardisation. Interoperability for data sharing should be addressed.

Clustering and cooperation with other selected projects under this topic and other relevant topics in Horizon Europe (e.g., HORIZON-CL4-2023-TWIN-TRANSITION-01-42 or HORIZON-CL4-2023-RESILIENCE-01-05), with European initiatives (as for example: Circular Cities and Regions Initiative (CCRI) and European Circular Economy Stakeholder Panel (ECESP)), as well as building on existing projects is strongly encouraged (see also Industrial Symbiosis Report of March 2020[4]).

This topic aims to support the goals of the smart cities mission by contributing to a healthier urban industrial symbiosis through waste reduction.

This topic implements the co-programmed European partnership Processes4Planet.

Specific Topic Conditions:
Activities are expected to start at TRL 5 and achieve TRL 7 by the end of the project – see General Annex B.

[1]Not mandatory.

[2]at a scale that allows to take economical and technical decisions for a First of a kind (FOAK) plant.

[3]Waste incineration coupled with district heating is excluded.

[4]Study and portfolio review of the projects on industrial symbiosis in DG Research and Innovation: Findings and recommendations, March 2020 http://ec.europa.eu/info/publications/study-and-portfolio-review-projects-industrial-symbiosis-dg-research-and-innovation-findings-and-recommendations_en